Post History
It seems your main question is why all the comments to your question about reactance were deleted. I deleted them because they were no longer relevant. They pointed out problems with the question...
Answer
#3: Post edited
by
Olin Lathrop
·
2022-03-25T18:27:52Z (over 2 years ago)
It seems your main question is why all the comments to your question about reactance were deleted. I deleted them because they were no longer relevant. They pointed out problems with the question, and explained why it was closed. You then fixed the question, it was reopened, and has now gotten two answers. That's how the system is <i>supposed</i> to work.- From the <a href="https://electrical.codidact.com/help/intro">site help</a>:
- <blockquote>Think of comments as the scaffolding and construction lines used to build posts. When all done, they should be, and often are, removed.</blockquote>
- The comments to your question were handled according to this policy.
- I also think that your post looks better to others with the comments removed. All people see is a reasonable questions. Showing the dirty laundry it took to get there isn't in the site's interest, and not in yours either. I'm not sure what you hope to gain by keeping the comments.
- <hr>
- I am not going to address the part of your question about my actions on a different site. That has no place here on <i>this</i> site.
- It seems your main question is why all the comments to your question about reactance were deleted. I deleted them because they were no longer relevant. They pointed out problems with the question, and explained why it was closed. You then fixed the question, it was reopened, and it has now gotten two answers. That's how the system is <i>supposed</i> to work.
- From the <a href="https://electrical.codidact.com/help/intro">site help</a>:
- <blockquote>Think of comments as the scaffolding and construction lines used to build posts. When all done, they should be, and often are, removed.</blockquote>
- The comments to your question were handled according to this policy.
- I also think that your post looks better to others with the comments removed. All people see is a reasonable questions. Showing the dirty laundry it took to get there isn't in the site's interest, and not in yours either. I'm not sure what you hope to gain by keeping the comments.
- <hr>
- I am not going to address the part of your question about my actions on a different site. That has no place here on <i>this</i> site.
#2: Post edited
by
Olin Lathrop
·
2022-03-25T18:24:57Z (over 2 years ago)
- It seems your main question is why all the comments to your question about reactance were deleted. I deleted them because they were no longer relevant. They pointed out problems with the question, and explained why it was closed. You then fixed the question, it was reopened, and has now gotten two answers. That's how the system is <i>supposed</i> to work.
- From the <a href="https://electrical.codidact.com/help/intro">site help</a>:
- <blockquote>Think of comments as the scaffolding and construction lines used to build posts. When all done, they should be, and often are, removed.</blockquote>
- The comments to your question were handled according to this policy.
- I also think that your post looks better to others with the comments removed. All people see is a reasonable questions. Showing the dirty laundry it took to get there isn't in the site's interest, and not in yours either. I'm not sure what you hope to gain by keeping the comments.
- <hr>
I am not going to address the part of your question about my actions on a different site. That has no place here.
- It seems your main question is why all the comments to your question about reactance were deleted. I deleted them because they were no longer relevant. They pointed out problems with the question, and explained why it was closed. You then fixed the question, it was reopened, and has now gotten two answers. That's how the system is <i>supposed</i> to work.
- From the <a href="https://electrical.codidact.com/help/intro">site help</a>:
- <blockquote>Think of comments as the scaffolding and construction lines used to build posts. When all done, they should be, and often are, removed.</blockquote>
- The comments to your question were handled according to this policy.
- I also think that your post looks better to others with the comments removed. All people see is a reasonable questions. Showing the dirty laundry it took to get there isn't in the site's interest, and not in yours either. I'm not sure what you hope to gain by keeping the comments.
- <hr>
- I am not going to address the part of your question about my actions on a different site. That has no place here on <i>this</i> site.
#1: Initial revision
by
Olin Lathrop
·
2022-03-25T18:20:31Z (over 2 years ago)
It seems your main question is why all the comments to your question about reactance were deleted. I deleted them because they were no longer relevant. They pointed out problems with the question, and explained why it was closed. You then fixed the question, it was reopened, and has now gotten two answers. That's how the system is <i>supposed</i> to work. From the <a href="https://electrical.codidact.com/help/intro">site help</a>: <blockquote>Think of comments as the scaffolding and construction lines used to build posts. When all done, they should be, and often are, removed.</blockquote> The comments to your question were handled according to this policy. I also think that your post looks better to others with the comments removed. All people see is a reasonable questions. Showing the dirty laundry it took to get there isn't in the site's interest, and not in yours either. I'm not sure what you hope to gain by keeping the comments. <hr> I am not going to address the part of your question about my actions on a different site. That has no place here.