Communities

Writing
Writing
Codidact Meta
Codidact Meta
The Great Outdoors
The Great Outdoors
Photography & Video
Photography & Video
Scientific Speculation
Scientific Speculation
Cooking
Cooking
Electrical Engineering
Electrical Engineering
Judaism
Judaism
Languages & Linguistics
Languages & Linguistics
Software Development
Software Development
Mathematics
Mathematics
Christianity
Christianity
Code Golf
Code Golf
Music
Music
Physics
Physics
Linux Systems
Linux Systems
Power Users
Power Users
Tabletop RPGs
Tabletop RPGs
Community Proposals
Community Proposals
tag:snake search within a tag
answers:0 unanswered questions
user:xxxx search by author id
score:0.5 posts with 0.5+ score
"snake oil" exact phrase
votes:4 posts with 4+ votes
created:<1w created < 1 week ago
post_type:xxxx type of post
Search help
Notifications
Mark all as read See all your notifications »
Users Search
Help Dashboard Sign In Sign Up
Q&A Papers Meta
Q&A
Posts Tags Edits
Ask Question

Post History

60%
+1 −0
Q&A Noise from oscillator on top layer to clock on bottom layer with VCC & GND layers between

What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer PCB stack-up looks like a compromise. Clock is a high speed signal, and so is SPI dependi...

posted 5mo ago by Nick Alexeev‭  ·  edited 5mo ago by Nick Alexeev‭

Answer
#5: Post edited by user avatar Nick Alexeev‭ · 2023-12-02T15:40:20Z (5 months ago)
  • What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer PCB stack-up looks like a compromise. Clock is a high speed signal, and so is SPI depending on the edge raise time. What works as reference layer for these signals?
  • A high speed signal should have a reference plane layer next to it. A GND plane layer serves as good reference plane in theory and in practice. A VCC plane layer can serve as a reference plane in theory, but there are practical hindrances. If you want to route a signal through a via from the bottom layer which uses VCC plane as a reference to the top layer which uses GND plane as a reference, then you have to connect the reference planes near the signal via. How would you connect the reference planes if they are at different potentials? You would connect them through a coupling capacitor. But then you have to have a lot of these coupling capacitors, which isn't convenient.
  • As a result of the above considerations, there are two non-compromised options for 4-layer PCB stack-ups.
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • If not enough real estate for high speed signals on the top layer:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - GND plane
  • 4 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • If you find yourself hard pressed to do a 4-layer PCB with two GND planes, then consider a 6-layer PCB:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • 5 - GND plane
  • 6 – high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • That's a common stack-up for a 6-layer PCB, although not the only good 6-layer stack-up.
  • What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer PCB stack-up looks like a compromise. Clock is a high speed signal, and so is SPI depending on the edge raise time. Clock and SPI are on different layers: top and bottom. What acts as reference layers for these signals?
  • A high speed signal should have a reference plane layer next to it. A GND plane layer serves as good reference plane in theory and in practice. A VCC plane layer can serve as a reference plane in theory, but there are practical hindrances. If you want to route a signal through a via from the bottom layer which uses VCC plane as a reference to the top layer which uses GND plane as a reference, then you have to connect the reference planes near the signal via. How would you connect the reference planes if they are at different potentials? You would connect them through a coupling capacitor. But then you have to have a lot of these coupling capacitors, which isn't convenient.
  • As a result of the above considerations, there are two non-compromised options for 4-layer PCB stack-ups.
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • If not enough real estate for high speed signals on the top layer:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - GND plane
  • 4 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • If you find yourself hard pressed to do a 4-layer PCB with two GND planes, then consider a 6-layer PCB:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • 5 - GND plane
  • 6 – high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • That's a common stack-up for a 6-layer PCB, although not the only good 6-layer stack-up.
#4: Post edited by user avatar Nick Alexeev‭ · 2023-12-01T17:58:40Z (5 months ago)
  • What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer PCB stack-up looks like a compromise.
  • A high speed signal should have a reference plane layer next to it. A GND plane layer serves as good reference plane in theory and in practice. A VCC plane layer can serve as a reference plane in theory, but there are practical hindrances. If you want to route a signal through a via from the bottom layer which uses VCC plane as a reference to the top layer which uses GND plane as a reference, then you have to connect the reference planes near the signal via. How would you connect the reference planes if they are at different potentials? You would connect them through a coupling capacitor. But then you have to have a lot of these coupling capacitors, which isn't convenient.
  • As a result of the above considerations, there are two non-compromised options for 4-layer PCB stack-ups.
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • If not enough real estate for high speed signals on the top layer:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - GND plane
  • 4 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • If you find yourself hard pressed to do a 4-layer PCB with two GND planes, then consider a 6-layer PCB:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • 5 - GND plane
  • 6 – high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • That's a common stack-up for a 6-layer PCB, although not the only good 6-layer stack-up.
  • What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer PCB stack-up looks like a compromise. Clock is a high speed signal, and so is SPI depending on the edge raise time. What works as reference layer for these signals?
  • A high speed signal should have a reference plane layer next to it. A GND plane layer serves as good reference plane in theory and in practice. A VCC plane layer can serve as a reference plane in theory, but there are practical hindrances. If you want to route a signal through a via from the bottom layer which uses VCC plane as a reference to the top layer which uses GND plane as a reference, then you have to connect the reference planes near the signal via. How would you connect the reference planes if they are at different potentials? You would connect them through a coupling capacitor. But then you have to have a lot of these coupling capacitors, which isn't convenient.
  • As a result of the above considerations, there are two non-compromised options for 4-layer PCB stack-ups.
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • If not enough real estate for high speed signals on the top layer:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - GND plane
  • 4 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • If you find yourself hard pressed to do a 4-layer PCB with two GND planes, then consider a 6-layer PCB:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • 5 - GND plane
  • 6 – high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • That's a common stack-up for a 6-layer PCB, although not the only good 6-layer stack-up.
#3: Post edited by user avatar Nick Alexeev‭ · 2023-12-01T17:50:34Z (5 months ago)
  • What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer PCB stack-up looks like a compromise.
  • A high speed signal should have a reference plane layer next to it. A GND plane layer serves as good reference plane in theory and in practice. A VCC plane layer can serve as a reference plane in theory, but there are practical hindrances. If you want to route a signal through a via from the bottom layer which uses VCC plane as a reference to the top layer which uses GND plane as a reference, then you have to connect the reference planes near the signal via. How would you connect the reference planes if they are at different potentials? You would connect them through a coupling capacitor. But then you have to have a lot of these coupling capacitors, which isn't convenient.
  • As a result of the above considerations, there are two non-compromised options for 4-layer PCB stack-ups.
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • If not enough real estate for high speed signals on the top layer:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - GND plane
  • 4 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • If you are hard pressed to do a 4-layer PCB with two GND planes, then consider a 6-layer PCB:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • 5 - GND plane
  • 6 – high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer PCB stack-up looks like a compromise.
  • A high speed signal should have a reference plane layer next to it. A GND plane layer serves as good reference plane in theory and in practice. A VCC plane layer can serve as a reference plane in theory, but there are practical hindrances. If you want to route a signal through a via from the bottom layer which uses VCC plane as a reference to the top layer which uses GND plane as a reference, then you have to connect the reference planes near the signal via. How would you connect the reference planes if they are at different potentials? You would connect them through a coupling capacitor. But then you have to have a lot of these coupling capacitors, which isn't convenient.
  • As a result of the above considerations, there are two non-compromised options for 4-layer PCB stack-ups.
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • If not enough real estate for high speed signals on the top layer:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - GND plane
  • 4 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • If you find yourself hard pressed to do a 4-layer PCB with two GND planes, then consider a 6-layer PCB:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • 5 - GND plane
  • 6 – high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • That's a common stack-up for a 6-layer PCB, although not the only good 6-layer stack-up.
#2: Post edited by user avatar Nick Alexeev‭ · 2023-12-01T17:30:31Z (5 months ago)
  • What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer stack-up looks like a compromise.
  • A high speed signal should have a reference plane layer next to it. A GND plane layer serves as good reference plane in theory and in practice. A VCC plane layer can serve as a reference plane in theory, but there are practical hindrances. If you want to route a signal through a via from the bottom layer which uses VCC plane as a reference to the top layer which uses GND plane as a reference, then you have to connect the reference planes near the signal via. How would you connect the reference planes if they are at different potentials? You would connect them through a coupling capacitor. But then you have to have a lot of these coupling capacitors, which isn't convenient.
  • As a result of the above considerations, there are two non-compromised options for 4-layer PCB stack-ups.
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • If not enough real estate for high speed signals on the top layer:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - GND plane
  • 4 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • If you are hard pressed to do a 4-layer PCB with two GND planes, then consider a 6-layer PCB:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • 5 - GND plane
  • 6 – high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer PCB stack-up looks like a compromise.
  • A high speed signal should have a reference plane layer next to it. A GND plane layer serves as good reference plane in theory and in practice. A VCC plane layer can serve as a reference plane in theory, but there are practical hindrances. If you want to route a signal through a via from the bottom layer which uses VCC plane as a reference to the top layer which uses GND plane as a reference, then you have to connect the reference planes near the signal via. How would you connect the reference planes if they are at different potentials? You would connect them through a coupling capacitor. But then you have to have a lot of these coupling capacitors, which isn't convenient.
  • As a result of the above considerations, there are two non-compromised options for 4-layer PCB stack-ups.
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • If not enough real estate for high speed signals on the top layer:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - GND plane
  • 4 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • If you are hard pressed to do a 4-layer PCB with two GND planes, then consider a 6-layer PCB:
  • 1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals
  • 2 - GND plane
  • 3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
  • 4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
  • 5 - GND plane
  • 6 – high speed signals, sensitive signals
#1: Initial revision by user avatar Nick Alexeev‭ · 2023-12-01T17:29:21Z (5 months ago) 
What you are proposing may be okay (depending on other specifics of the design), but your proposed 4-layer stack-up looks like a compromise.

A high speed signal should have a reference plane layer next to it.  A GND plane layer serves as good reference plane in theory and in practice.  A VCC plane layer can serve as a reference plane in theory, but there are practical hindrances.  If you want to route a signal through a via from the bottom layer which uses VCC plane as a reference to the top layer which uses GND plane as a reference, then you have to connect the reference planes near the signal via.  How would you connect the reference planes if they are at different potentials?  You would connect them through a coupling capacitor.  But then you have to have a lot of these coupling capacitors, which isn't convenient.

As a result of the above considerations, there are two non-compromised options for 4-layer PCB stack-ups.

    1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals 
    2 - GND plane
    3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
    4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals

If not enough real estate for high speed signals on the top layer:

    1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals 
    2 - GND plane
    3 - GND plane
    4 - high speed signals, sensitive signals 

If you are hard pressed to do a 4-layer PCB with two GND planes, then consider a 6-layer PCB:

    1 - high speed signals, sensitive signals 
    2 - GND plane
    3 - VCC plane, other power distribution
    4 - low speed and non-sensitive signals
    5 - GND plane
    6 – high speed signals, sensitive signals